A couple of days ago, I finished reading The Comeback Season by Jennifer E. Smith. (If that name rings a bell, it’s probably because she also wrote The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight…which I reviewed in March of this year.) As a baseball fan, I was intrigued with the idea of a love story that essentially centered on a baseball team—even one that I’m not crazy about. (The Chicago Cubs are featured in this book. I’m a life-long Atlanta Braves fan. Sadly, fans of both teams have grown accustomed to disappointment.)
Anyhoo, I was prepared for a light, fun read with lots of sports metaphors and a couple growing closer through their love of the game. In one sense, I got what I was expecting. In another, however, I got so much more. The Comeback Season is much more than a love story. Yes, there’s a tale of young love, but it’s also a book about moving forward and surviving…even when all hope is seemingly lost.
Ryan Walsh loves the Chicago Cubs. It’s something she shared with her dad. She loves the Cubs so much that she’s skipping school to catch opening day at Wrigley Field…on the tenth anniversary of her dad’s death. (She’ll probably have more fun there anyway, even if the Cubs lose as they so often do, and even if this day brings back some pretty painful memories. School is not exactly a good experience for Ryan.) She doesn’t know what to think, though, when she runs into Nick, the new kid in school, also trying to score a ticket to watch the Cubs play. Sadly, neither Ryan nor Nick gets a ticket to the game, but they do strike up a tentative friendship based on their mutual love for the Chicago Cubs.
When Ryan returns to school the next morning, she’s not quite sure how to act around Nick. Are they school friends or baseball friends? Will he be like every other person in school—even people Ryan once considered friends—and act like she’s invisible? Much to Ryan’s surprise, Nick acknowledges her existence and seems to not care that she’s an outcast. Their mutual love for the Cubs—and the hope that the team will have a good year—brings them together like nothing else could.
There may be something else, though, with the power to tear Ryan and Nick apart. Something that neither of them knows how to fight. Something that makes them question everything they’ve ever known or hoped for. Nick is hiding a big secret, and when Ryan discovers what’s going on, she begins to lose faith in everything…including the baseball team that’s carried her through some of her toughest moments.
Ryan doesn’t think the Cubs will be enough this time, and she doesn’t know how to deal with the turmoil that is sure to come. Ryan is losing the hope that is a part of every Cubs fan’s world, and she’s not sure how to get it back…or if she can, especially when it becomes clear that Nick—her only friend in the world and the boy who’s stolen her heart—is about to face something much more difficult than a baseball game. Will this be a losing season for Ryan and Nick, or will they be able to come back from the biggest slump either of them has ever faced? Read The Comeback Season by Jennifer E. Smith to learn how true Cubs fans hold onto hope even in the toughest of times.
I did enjoy this book, even though I was less than thrilled with the ending. I hate to say this, but The Comeback Season reminded me a little of John Green’s The Fault in Our Stars (probably the best book I’ve read so far this year). I didn’t like this because, even at the beginning of this book, I had a feeling that I knew what was coming…and how I was going to react to it. (I was right.) Now, The Comeback Season, in my opinion, wasn’t nearly as good as The Fault in Our Stars, but the trials of at least one of the characters were similar to what happened in TFiOS. Do with that what you will.